Executive Summary
Many governments around the world have put in place systems to help ensure that investments in changes such as infrastructure projects, government programs or new national laws do not bring undue harm to their citizens or environment. The effectiveness of these systems in successfully preventing negative impacts varies widely. Developing countries tend to have a particularly difficult time ensuring that investments within their borders meet minimum social and environmental standards. As a result, many financial institutions have established their own policies to help ensure that their investments do not result in harm to vulnerable communities or ecosystems. These policies are generally known as “safeguards.” Although safeguard policies provide vital protection against risks to people and the environment, properly designing and implementing these policies means navigating complex relationships between financial institutions, governments, and the citizens of recipient countries.
The World Bank (the Bank) has been at the forefront among multilateral development banks in developing safeguard policies. In recent decades, the Bank has experimented with different approaches to social and environmental protection. These approaches respond in part to variations in the way in which countries receive money from the Bank, such as investments in projects versus policies. They have also emerged in reaction to the changing global landscape. Some developing countries have become richer and created stronger systems to protect people and the environment. The global community has also realized the value of letting developing countries define their own development path. At the same time, the pressing need to protect our global common goods and most vulnerable communities has become more apparent.
This working paper seeks to help the Bank and other financial institutions take stock of experiences to date and distill lessons for the future. We look at four different approaches to protecting against social and environmental harm: the traditional safeguards approach, which applies to most project lending; the Use of Country Systems approach, which the Bank has applied to some project lending on a pilot basis; the approach used for Program for Results investments, which applies to the Bank’s results-based lending pilot; and the approach used for Development Policy Loans, which applies to loans that support changes to policies and institutions.
While all four of these approaches rely on the rules and institutions of the recipient country, they do so to different degrees. Through an analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of each of approach, we arrive at seven lessons for the World Bank and other financial institutions looking to balance ownership and accountabil¬ity in their social and environmental policies:
- Building on country safeguard systems can enhance ownership and incentives for safeguard implementation.
- Minimum standards and positive incentives can clarify requirements and encourage countries to strive toward more ambitious social and environmental goals.
- Safeguard implementation requires anticipating risks, planning to deal with those risks, managing and monitoring implementation, and responding to harm.
- Proper safeguard implementation requires people on the ground to engage, collaborate and problem solve.
- Recipient country safeguard systems still need support.
- Citizens play a key role in any effective safeguard system.
- To successfully balance ownership and accountability, safeguard approaches need to recognize differences among countries, sectors, and projects.
Pace Environmental Notes, the weblog of the Pace University School of Law’s Environmental Collection, is a gateway to news, recent books and articles, information resources, and legal research strategies relevant to the fields of environmental, energy, land use, animal law and other related disciplines.
Showing posts with label Environmental Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environmental Justice. Show all posts
Friday, May 3, 2013
WRI Working Paper Released: Striking the Balance: Ownership and Accountability in Social and Environmental Safeguards
Recently, the World Resources Institute, a global environmental think tank whose mission is “to move human society to live in ways that protect Earth’s environment and its capacity to provide for the needs and aspirations of current and future generations,” released a report authored by Gaia Larsen and Athena Ballesteros titled, Striking the Balance: Ownership and Accountability in Social and Environmental Safeguards (2013). The 28-page report available here discusses the following:
Tuesday, April 9, 2013
ELI Seminar: Meet & Greet: Matthew Tejada, Incoming Director of EPA’s Office of Environmental Justice

| Meet & Greet: Matthew Tejada, Incoming Director of EPA’s Office of Environmental Justice |
|||||
| An ELI Research Seminar | |||||
|
|||||
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Congressional Budget Office Report Released: Offsetting a Carbon Tax’s Costs on Low-Income Households
Recently, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), a nonpartisan governmental agency responsible for "analy[zing] . . . budgetary and economic issues to support the Congressional budget process" issued a working paper titled, Offsetting a Carbon Tax’s Costs on Low-Income Households (No. 2012-16). According to the 19-page report, available here, authored by Terry Dinan,
[i]mposing a tax on carbon dioxide emissions would reduce the damage from climate change but would also impose a larger burden, relative to income, on low-income households than on high-income households. This paper evaluates two broad groupings of options for reducing the regressive effects of a carbon tax; one group of options would affect large segments of the economy, for example by reducing payroll taxes, and the other group of options would be targeted at low-income households, for example by providing an additional payment to households currently receiving electronic transfer benefits. Each option is evaluated based on the percent of low-income households that it would affect, whether it would provide comparatively larger benefits for lower-income households, its administrative costs, and its implications for economic efficiency, specifically whether it would increase incentives to work and invest and whether it would preserve the incentives to reduce emissions that the carbon tax would create. The broad based options could potentially provide support for a relatively large share of low-income households, but some of those options would provide relatively small benefits to those households. Options specifically targeting low-income households could be most effective in reaching households that do not file income taxes or that do not have earnings. Three of the seven options considered would increase the incentive to work or invest and all but one of the options would preserve the incentive to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide.
Friday, October 26, 2012
International Union for the Conservation of Nature Report Released: Livelihoods and Landscapes Strategy: Results and Resolutions
This month, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) released a report titled, Livelihoods and Landscapes Strategy: Results and Resolutions. The 47-page report available here, as a downloadable pdf discusses the
Livelihoods and Landscapes Strategy (LLS) . . . a five-year program implemented by IUCN, focusing on four main themes: poverty reduction, natural resource-based markets and incentives, forest governance, and landscape transformation. This final report summarizes the objectives, activities, outcomes and impacts of LLS up to December 2011, and reflects on the learning and the lessons that have been generated by the Strategy.
Related Links:
Livelihood and Landscapes Strategy, IUCN (last visited Oct. 26, 2012).Thursday, September 13, 2012
Congressional Research Service Report Released: Global Access to Clean Drinking Water and Sanitation: U.S. and International Programs
The Congressional Research Service (CRS), the public policy research arm of Congress, just issued the report Global Access to Clean Drinking Water and Sanitation: U.S. and International Programs (Sept. 10, 2012). The 40 page report authored by Tiaji Salaam- Blyther discusses the
bilateral WASH schemes authorized by the Water for the Poor Act. These programs are monitored and reported by the Department of State and implemented primarily by USAID and the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC). In FY2009, USAID and MCC accounted for roughly 90% of all U.S. spending on the issue. [ ] Broader water-related efforts supported by other U.S. agencies and departments[ ]are not addressed, nor are water and sanitation efforts implemented by a variety of international actors—including multilateral groups like the World Bank, private businesses like Procter and Gamble, and foundations like the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. This report identifies some issues that donors and U.S. agencies face while carrying out global drinking water and sanitation projects.
Wednesday, November 17, 2010
Budapest Call for Climate Justice
The World Council of Churches has made a final statement that underlines that the methods of wealth creation and the pursuit of unlimited wealth in rich industrialised countries of Europe often impoverish communities and harm creation as a whole.
The document indicates that: "Climate justice and therefore both social and ecological values should be a central goal of policy-making. In industrialized countries economic growth should no longer be seen as an aim in itself."
The statement calls for "the redistribution of wealth and sharing of technology between rich countries and poor countries affected by climate change" as "crucial elements of climate justice". This has to go along with "additional support for climate change mitigation and adaptation."
The document indicates that: "Climate justice and therefore both social and ecological values should be a central goal of policy-making. In industrialized countries economic growth should no longer be seen as an aim in itself."
The statement calls for "the redistribution of wealth and sharing of technology between rich countries and poor countries affected by climate change" as "crucial elements of climate justice". This has to go along with "additional support for climate change mitigation and adaptation."
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Making Peace In and With the World: The Role of the Gülen Movement in the Task of Eco-Justice -- Gülen Conference
With a case of Gülen’s thought and the Gülen Movement, the conference aims to explore two dimensions of peace in humanity. First, making peace between differing human communities, and second, making peace between the human community and the living and limited world that embraces us and makes our life possible. The phrase “eco-justice” states this dual reality, as global economic justice must go hand in hand with global ecological justice if “peace” is to be made.
November 04, 2010
Howard Gittis Student Center South (Room 200C),
13th St. & Montgomery Avenue
Temple University, Philadelphia, PA 19122
November 04, 2010
Howard Gittis Student Center South (Room 200C),
13th St. & Montgomery Avenue
Temple University, Philadelphia, PA 19122
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
EPA’s Action Development Process: Interim Guidance on Considering Environmental Justice During the Development of an Action
TThis step-by-step Guide (dated July 2010) will help EPA staff determine whether EPA actions raise possible environmental justice concerns and will encourage public participation in the rulemaking process. Further, the Guide will support us in meeting our responsibilities under Executive Order 12898, Federal Actions To Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-lncome Populations, and EPA's regulatory authorities to consider the needs of'minority, low-income, and indigenous populations overburdened by pollution.
The purpose of this Guide is to explicitly integrate Environmental Justice considerations into the fabric of EPA’s ADP—from rule inception through all the stages leading to promulgation and implementation—requiring that workgroups meaningfully engage with and consider the impacts on minority, low-income, and indigenous populations, and tribes.
The purpose of this Guide is to explicitly integrate Environmental Justice considerations into the fabric of EPA’s ADP—from rule inception through all the stages leading to promulgation and implementation—requiring that workgroups meaningfully engage with and consider the impacts on minority, low-income, and indigenous populations, and tribes.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Chemical Products and Toxic Torts at a Crossroads: New Developments, Significant Trends, and a View into the Future
This ABA Regional CLE Workshop is an interactive seminar involving nationally known plaintiffs’ lawyers, members of the judiciary, in-house counsel and defense-oriented trial lawyers who will discuss new developments and significant trends in toxic and mass torts involving chemicals and industrial products, including a look at the impact of a post-Bush, recessionary world on pending and future litigation, the use of biomonitoring and toxicogenomics to determine medical causation, the evolution of environmental justice and nuisance theories, and the next wave of litigation involving household products.
September 11, 2009
8:00 AM – 3:30 PM
at: Exxon Mobil Corporation, Houston, TX
Registration Deadline: September 7, 2009
September 11, 2009
8:00 AM – 3:30 PM
at: Exxon Mobil Corporation, Houston, TX
Registration Deadline: September 7, 2009
Monday, June 29, 2009
Environmental Justice Resource Guide
This publication produced by the Environmental Protection Agency's Region 9 (EPA-909-R-09-001) provides information and access to EPA’s funding sources, training opportunities, and technical and program assistance. The guide highlights recent successes in communities affected by environmental injustices and references some of the tools these communities have used to achieve results.
This publication will also help organizations, agencies, and academics who
work with Environmental Justice (EJ) communities to recognize opportunities
to help their constituents.
This publication will also help organizations, agencies, and academics who
work with Environmental Justice (EJ) communities to recognize opportunities
to help their constituents.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



